Shelby County Schools fires basketball coach, sets timeline for policy reforms

Anonymous reporting system, outside investigators, and required training all have scheduled timelines.

"I'm Shay McAlister, and this is Shay Informed: an independent, ad-free platform dedicated to honest journalism with compassion and clarity.

Are you new here? Sign up for the free weekly newsletter or subscribe to support our mission and access behind-the-scenes content, podcasts, and in-depth stories reserved for paid subscribers.

Chris Gaither is no longer employed by Shelby County Schools.

The former Martha Layne Collins High School basketball coach was terminated effective January 15th by Superintendent Dr. Joshua Matthews, citing "multiple Board of Education policies," according to a district statement released this week.

But here's something important to understand: The termination isn't necessarily final.

Due process continues

Under Kentucky law, certified employees have the right to appeal, and request a hearing, also known as a tribunal. If Gaither exercises that right, the Kentucky Commissioner of Education will appoint an independent three-member tribunal to hear his case and make a ruling. The tribunal will include a teacher, an administrator, and an attorney who serves as hearing officer. None of the tribunal members will be from Shelby County.

That tribunal hears sworn testimony from witnesses, then issues a recommendation to either uphold or overturn the superintendent's decision. The hearing officer then issues a final order.

If the decision is overturned, Gaither would be reinstated and entitled to full back pay. If upheld, he could still appeal to a court.

Gaither has 10 days to request the tribunal, and it will be up to him if the hearing is private or public.

Policy changes- with actual dates

More than a month after the community demanded reforms at a contentious December 12th school board meeting, the district is now providing concrete timelines for policy changes.

Here's what they're committing to:

1. New anonymous reporting system - March 2026

The district already has a tip line, but they're adding another reporting option with a projected launch date of March 2026. This new system would provide an additional avenue for students, staff, and parents to report concerns.

2. Third-party investigators - Policy coming this month

The district says it will present a policy to the Board of Education "at a meeting later this month" that would establish third-party investigation processes for "all student and staff sexual misconduct allegations, as well as other complex cases."

This is significant. It means outside investigators would handle these cases going forward- not district personnel.

The district notes that the Education Professional Standards Board and Child Protective Services already conduct independent investigations when cases meet their criteria. This policy would formalize the use of third-party investigators more broadly.

3. Required staff training - Starting February 17th

All staff will be required to attend professional development sessions led by Ali Parham from Homeland Security. The sessions are scheduled for February 17th, February 24th, March 13th, and April 24th.

How we got here

These policy changes come after weeks of community pressure following allegations against Gaither.

On December 4th, Hayley Weddle- a 2014 graduate- filed a written complaint detailing what she said was an inappropriate relationship that began when she was 16 and a team manager on his basketball team.

The district opened an investigation the next day. But five days later, Gaither was still teaching and coaching.

When Weddle saw him on the sidelines December 9th, she posted her statement publicly on social media.

"I had tried to go through the appropriate channels, but it did not feel like they were going to do anything," Weddle told me. "It felt like it would be swept under the rug, as it has been before."

Within hours of her post, multiple people contacted the district with additional information. That's when Gaither was suspended- December 10th.

Weddle described a pattern of behavior that started during her junior year: late-night messages on Snapchat, comments about her appearance, being pulled out of class, and questions about her relationships and sexual history.

Two weeks after graduation, she said she was babysitting Gaither's children when he kissed her. The next day, they had sex. She was 18. He was her former coach.

"I blamed myself for years," Weddle said. "But he had been grooming me since I was 16."

The community demands action

Two days after Gaither's suspension, on December 12th, parents, former students, and staff packed a school board meeting with specific demands:

• Independent investigation of how past allegations were handled
• Close post-graduation loopholes
• Explicitly define grooming behaviors
• Require annual public reporting of misconduct investigations

"Secrecy is what allows abuse to thrive," former student Laura Wills-Coppelman told the board. "Choose to act before another student is harmed."

From proposals to timeline

On January 7th- nearly a month after Weddle filed her complaint- Superintendent Matthews sent a letter outlining proposed policy changes. But that letter provided no timeline, no implementation dates, just promises that the district was "working on" recommendations.

This week's statement is different. It includes actual dates. March for the new reporting system. February for the first training session. A policy presentation to the board "later this month."

It's still not everything the community asked for. There's no mention of an independent review of how past allegations were handled. No commitment to annual public reporting of misconduct investigations.

But it's more concrete than what came before.

Supporting the proposed grooming law

The district also announced support for HB4, a bill introduced last Tuesday by Representative Marianna Proctor. The legislation would fill a gap in the current law, targeting predatory behavior that leads to sexual abuse.

Kentucky lawmakers push to criminalize child grooming before abuse occurs

The legislation would fill a gap in the current law, targeting predatory behavior that leads to sexual abuse. “I’m Shay McAlister, and this is Shay Informed: an independent, ad-free platform dedicated to honest journalism with compassion and clarity. Are you new here? Sign up for the free weekly newsletter or

Shay InformedShay McAlister

The Shelby County investigation into Chris Gaither illustrates exactly what prosecutors say House Bill 4 could address- behavior that may not rise to the level of criminal sexual solicitation or assault under current law, but is "nevertheless clearly inappropriate and clearly designed to lead to such things," as Boone County Commonwealth Attorney Louis Kelly put it.

What comes next

For Hayley Weddle, who carried this secret for a decade before coming forward, Gaither's termination represents accountability- even if the due process could potentially reverse it.

For the community that walked out of that December meeting feeling unheard, these policy timelines represent progress- even if questions remain about implementation and enforcement.

And for the district trying to rebuild trust, these commitments will be measured not by announcements but by follow-through.

Like what you see? Learn more about Shay Informed here! This is honest journalism with compassion and clarity.