Zach Dembo’s win and what it could mean for Beshear’s 2028 pitch

A Kentucky political scientist says the Governor’s victory-night speech sounded a lot like the case he’d make to Democrats nationwide.

I'm Shay McAlister, and this is Shay Informed: an independent, ad-free platform dedicated to honest journalism with compassion and clarity.

I believe some stories are too important to stay behind a paywall. That's why I'm making this piece free to read for everyone. Informed communities make better decisions and that can only happen when people have access to honest, thorough reporting.

Shay Informed is 100% reader-funded. No ads. No corporate backing. Just journalism that answers to you. If you'd like to help keep this work going, please consider subscribing.

When Zach Dembo took the stage for his victory speech Tuesday night, the person who introduced him was Gov. Andy Beshear. According to one political scientist, that was probably not an accident.

Dr. Stephen Voss stayed up late watching the election results. His read of the moment is that Beshear wasn’t just celebrating a win. He was previewing a pitch.

A message Beshear has been selling

Voss said Dembo, who flipped the 6th Congressional District, embodies the argument Beshear has been making to Democrats nationally. Beshear spelled it out in his introduction of the Lexington-area Democrat on Tuesday night.

"He had so much integrity, he refused for his position to be weaponized", Beshear of Dembo's role as a federal prosecutor. "He said no to Donald Trump then. He's going to have a lot of chances to say no to Donald Trump now."

Dembo’s resume doesn’t read like a typical national-Democrat profile. He’s a ninth-generation Kentuckian who has worked as a teacher, a military lawyer, a policy advisor to Gov. Beshear and most recently a US Attorney.

His break with Washington, D.C. became the heart of his campaign- resigning from the Justice Department over what he called political concerns and corruption.

On stage Tuesday night, Beshear touted Dembo's success as a sign of something larger. "We proved that Kentucky is not as red as the rest of the country thinks we are", Beshear said.

Dembo worked in Beshear's administration before joining the DOJ. The two have a past, but Voss doesn't think that's the reason they were in the same room Tuesday night.

“I don’t think it’s a coincidence that Governor Beshear was the person who introduced Dembo for his victory speech,” Voss said. Instead, Voss believes it was an opportunity.

"You never know when you're going to be that generation that has to stand up and protect our democracy, the generation that has to do this work to make sure every branch of government works, the generation that proves that our Constitution is still worth fighting for," Beshear said on stage, "Tonight is the beginning to overcome our generation's McCarthyism, to make sure the Trump administration is viewed as an aberration and not the new normal."

Over the last year, Beshear gave Dembo a lot of support, Voss said, “but he also drew support from him.”

In Voss’s telling, what Beshear said in that introduction sounded much like the speech he might give on a presidential campaign trail. The pitch is that 'Democrats like us' can win in places where Democrats don’t normally win. And if the party nominates him, Voss said, Beshear’s message amounts to this: “Nominate me for president, and you might win a campaign that you otherwise would lose for the White House.”

Beshear has not announced a presidential run, and Voss didn’t claim to know what he’ll do. When I asked whether anything from Tuesday suggests how an announcement might land, Voss framed it conditionally: “Should he move forward down that path,” the Dembo moment fits the case he’d make.

Why Dembo works as the proof

Voss said he saw Dembo’s path early. He told people from the start that a Democrat could win the 6th District, which has voted Republican for the last decade but includes communities that have been shifting blue, including much of Fayette County. A year with Republicans holding the White House and Congress, he said, made for a favorable climate.

What he couldn’t know was whether Dembo would get the support to pull an upset. That became clear as the cycle went on. National Democrats made the race a priority, more money came in, and Dembo became a candidate who could “surprise people.”

That’s the kind of story a potential presidential candidate wants to tell. A Democrat wins in a district that leans Republican on paper, and a Democratic governor is there to stand beside him.

Voss describes himself as a nonpartisan commentator, but he was hired by the Kentucky Attorney General’s office, then Republican, in the redistricting litigation. His argument then was that Democrats were too focused on tweaking election rules to gain a seat or two, and not focused enough on recruiting candidates who could win over swing voters.

He said Dembo’s win validates that argument, and it’s the same logic behind Beshear’s pitch. “If a party really wants to make a difference, don’t worry so much about tweaking the rules,” Voss said. “Focus more on recruiting candidates who are near where the center, the swing voter, wants them to be.”

Voss said the GOP's Kentucky roots aren’t that deep. Kentucky was a Democratic stronghold in the 1990s, he said, and “this is not even one generation’s worth of Republican voting.” Many Kentuckians who vote Republican don’t think of themselves as Republicans, he said, and plenty of them are still registered Democrats. They just don’t like what they see from the national party.

“Give them an Andy Beshear, give them a Zach Dembo,” Voss said. “A lot of those so-called Kentucky Republicans show that they’ve got some blue in their mix too.”

That’s the case Beshear would need to make outside Kentucky, and Tuesday night gave him a fresh example to point to.

Like what you see? Learn more about Shay Informed here! This is honest journalism with compassion and clarity.