Kentucky State Police confirm active investigation into former Shelby County coach
– 5 min read
Kentucky State Police are asking for the public's help with an active investigation into a high school basketball coach accused of sexual misconduct.
"I'm Shay McAlister, and this is Shay Informed: an independent, ad-free platform dedicated to honest journalism with compassion and clarity.
Are you new here? Sign up for the free weekly newsletter or subscribe to support our mission and access behind-the-scenes content, podcasts, and in-depth stories reserved for paid subscribers.
Kentucky State Police have confirmed there is an open and active criminal investigation into former Shelby County Schools basketball coach Chris Gaither- and they need your help.
KSP Post 12 out of Frankfort says the investigation has been underway since January of this year. Anyone with information is encouraged to call 502-227-2221.
For those of you who have been following this story since the beginning, this is a significant development. For those just catching up, here's where we are and how we got here.
How it started
It began in December 2025, when Hayley Weddle- a 2014 graduate of Martha Layne Collins High School- filed a written complaint with Shelby County Schools detailing what she described as an inappropriate relationship that began when she was 16 years old and serving as a team manager on Gaither's basketball team.
The district opened an investigation the next day. But five days later, Gaither was still in the building- and still on the sidelines coaching a game.
When Weddle saw that, she made a decision. She posted her statement publicly.
"I had tried to go through the appropriate channels, but it did not feel like they were going to do anything," she told me at the time. "It felt like it would be swept under the rug, as it has been before."
Within hours of her post, multiple people contacted the district with additional information. Gaither was suspended December 10th. The community packed a school board meeting two days later, demanding accountability and concrete policy reform.
"I blamed myself for years," Weddle said. "But he had been grooming me since I was 16."
It's also worth noting: this was not the first time Gaither had been investigated. A prior investigation had been launched and closed after board attorneys said they found no evidence of wrongdoing. Weddle's complaint reopened it.
‘He has been able to hide for so long’; Shelby Co. Schools suspends coach after sexual misconduct allegations
A former team manager told me her relationship with Chris Gaither began while she was a student at Martha Layne Collins High School. “He has been able to hide for so long under the assumption that he is a good Christian pillar of this community, and I think it was
Shay McAlister
The termination- and then the settlement
In January 2026, Superintendent Dr. Joshua Matthews terminated Gaither, citing violations of multiple Board of Education policies. I told you at the time that the termination wasn't necessarily final- and it wasn't.
Under Kentucky law, Gaither had the right to appeal to an independent three-member tribunal. He exercised that right. But the hearing never happened. Instead, both sides went to mediation through the Attorney General's office, and a settlement was reached this spring.
Shelby County Coach accused of sexual misconduct wasn’t fired after all. A settlement quietly rewrote the ending.
A settlement agreement shows the district voided the termination, paid out his salary, and closed the case before it ever reached a tribunal- the hearing that serves as an appeals option for fired teachers. “I’m Shay McAlister, and this is Shay Informed: an independent, ad-free platform dedicated to
Shay McAlister
Under the terms of that agreement, which I obtained through an open records request, the district voided Gaither's termination letter and accepted his resignation instead, effective June 30, 2026. He was paid his remaining salary through the end of the school year- $37,907.72- plus a $5,000 lump sum from the district's insurance carrier. Nearly $43,000 total to walk away.
No sworn testimony was ever heard. No independent ruling was ever made on whether the termination was justified. The settlement stated plainly that neither party admits fault or misconduct.
Gaither agreed he will never seek re-employment with Shelby County Schools. But the agreement also required the documents to be submitted to the Education Professional Standards Board- the state body that has the power to suspend or revoke a teaching certificate. That review remains pending. I reached out to EPSB; they cannot comment on open investigations.
Now, KSP
The Kentucky State Police investigation has been running parallel to all of this since January. Their announcement this week is the first public confirmation that a criminal inquiry exists. I actually asked the agency about a possible investigation in January and did not receive a response. I asked again this week and this time, investigators confirmed it.
KSP Post 12 in Frankfort is seeking further information and is asking anyone who knows anything to reach out: 502-227-2221.
I want to be clear about what this means and what it doesn't. A KSP investigation is not a charge. It is not a conviction. But it does mean that law enforcement has found enough reason to keep looking- for six months now- and that they believe there are people out there who may have information they haven't yet shared.
If you're one of those people, now is the time.
‘You should be ashamed’; parents demand action at Shelby County School Board meeting
A school board meeting turned tense on Thursday night, as the room, filled with parents, staff, and former students, demanded answers in an ongoing sexual misconduct investigation. “I’m Shay McAlister, and this is Shay Informed: an independent, ad-free platform dedicated to honest journalism with compassion and clarity. Are
Shay McAlister
The bigger picture
The district has since implemented some of the policy changes it promised the community. Shelby County Schools is now under contract with Case IQ for an anonymous reporting system. A board attorney receives complaints and secures independent third-party investigators for misconduct cases. All certified staff received training this year, with annual training going forward and student trainings planned for the coming school year.
Those are real changes. They came because Hayley Weddle decided to speak up- even when it wasn't easy, even when the process felt slow, even when it seemed like nothing would happen.
Like what you see? Learn more about Shay Informed here! This is honest journalism with compassion and clarity.
